Search
Did Muhammad write the Quran? Did he plagiarize the Bible? Part II
Did Muhammad write the Quran? Did he
plagiarize the Bible? Part II
Fifth, a good portion of the Qur’an includes
stories of previous Prophets and their nations.
Always, the concluding remark is that the Prophet
had no previous knowledge of any of those stories
or historical events, and that he only knew of them
through revelation, for example:
- • After relating the story of Moses and Pharaoh
the Qur’an states: “You were not (there, O
Prophet,) on the western mountainside (of
Tur) when We decreed to Moses the
Commandments. Nor were you (there among
those) of the Children of Israel who bore
witness (to these events). Furthermore, We
brought forth (many) generations (after
Moses), such that the life spans (of
heedlessness) that stretched over them grew
(so very) long – (until they forgot God’s
Covenant). Moreover, you were not (there
with Moses when he was) dwelling among the
people of Midian, conveying Our message
unto them…” (28:44-45)
- • The Qur’an also states after the story of Jesus
and Mary: “This account of something that
was beyond the reach of your perception We
[now] reveal unto you: for you were not with
them when they drew lots as to which of them
should be Mary's guardian, and you were not
with them when they contended [about it]
with one another.” (3:44)
- • It also states after the story of Joseph: “This is
(but one) of the tidings of the unseen (past)
that We reveal to you, (O Prophet). For you
were not with them when they resolved (to
execute) their (evil) affair, and while they were
plotting (it).” (12:102)
Verses like the above appear routinely after
the stories in the Qur’an. Thus, if the Prophet had
learned these stories from Jews and Christians, why
should he ascribe them to God? Is he such a
blatant liar?
Sixth, the Qur’an severely criticized the
Prophet on several issues:
- • The Prophet was once sitting with some of
the leaders of Quraysh, inviting them to Islam.
A blind man, Abdullah bin Umm Makhtum,
who was already a Muslim, came to the
Prophet to ask him some questions regarding
Islam. The Prophet ignored him, as he was
busy delivering the message of Islam to the
leaders of Quraysh, hoping they would come
to Islam. Thereupon the revelation came
reproaching and reprimanding him: “He
frowned and turned away because the blind
man approached him. Yet for all you did
know (O Muhammad) he might perhaps have
grown in purity?” (80:1-3).
- • The Prophet used to love to eat honey. Once
he refused to consume any honey after his
wives discouraged him to do so, as a result of
a quarrel they were having among themselves.
God again reproached and reprimanded him:
“O Prophet! Why do you, out of a desire to
please [one or another of] your wives impose
[on yourself] a prohibition of something that
God has made lawful to you?” (66:1).
- • At the time of the battle of Tabuk, some
hypocrites came and asked the Prophet to
excuse them from participating in the
campaign. The merciful Prophet accepted
their excuse. Thereupon revelation came
down upon him again reproaching and
reprimanding him: “May God pardon you (O
Prophet)! Why did you grant them permission
(to stay at home) before it had become
obvious to you as to who was speaking truth
and (before) you came to know (who were)
the liars” (9:43).
There are many other incidents in which the
Prophet was reproached and reprimanded by God.
The logical question here is why would the Prophet
make up these verses? Even if someone had
revealed these verses to him, why would he retain
them while having a firm belief that these verses
will be recited and read throughout the ages? The
logical and factual answer is that these are not the
words of the Prophet, and he is not the author of
the Qur’an.
Seventh, one of the major themes of the
Qur’an is that the source of the Qur’an is God
Himself. The Prophet did not have any right to
add or subtract from what had been revealed:
If he (Muhammad) had dared to attribute
some of (his own) sayings unto Us, we would
indeed have seized him by his right hand and
would indeed have cut his life-vein.” (69:44-
46)
If the Prophet was really the author of the
Qur’an, why did he have to state these words?
Was he a sheer liar to the extent that he both
concocted the Qur’an and devised threats against
himself? History and logic would refute this
claim, especially since the Prophet was known
never to have uttered a lie in his whole life. Before
Prophethood, even the pagan idolaters attested to
his truthfulness, and he was known as the
“Trustworthy” and“Truthful” .Are we to believe
that suddenly, at the age of 40, the Prophet not
only began to utter a long string of lies but that
these lies were against God Himself? Simply
illogical!
https://www.mercyprophet.org/mul/node/6800
Ten Questions and Answers
about the Prophet Muhammad
May the Blessings and Peace of Allah be upon Him
By Ibrahim H. Malabari